Challenges In Aligning Physician Incentives to Quality Metrics and Quality Programs and How To Do It Correctly


Get Personalized Hospital Specific Presentation on Unified AI Quality, Safety, Risk & Incident Software


This article is part of the Dexur Insight, which is focused on Hospital Quality and Safety topics and is read by CEOs, CMOs, CNOs, CQOs, Quality, Safety, Compliance, Analytics & Performance teams. Please email dexurqualitysights@dexur5.com to join this newsletter and receive updates (not more than once per week).

Physicians play a pivotal role in healthcare delivery, with their patient care practices directly impacting overall outcomes and the effectiveness of healthcare organizations. By aligning physician incentives with quality metrics and quality programs, such as CMS Star Ratings, the Hospital Readmission Reduction Program (HRRP), and Value-Based Purchasing (VBP), healthcare organizations can achieve significant improvements in care delivery, operational efficiency, and financial performance. These programs measure key outcomes like readmission rates, mortality, and patient experiences, making it crucial to align incentives to these metrics. By doing so, hospitals can ensure that the quality of care is consistently high, patient satisfaction improves, and financial penalties for poor performance are minimized.

However, significant challenges remain in converting big-picture alignment into objective, actionable measures that incentives can be aligned to. For example, assume the Final CMS Published Risk Adjusted Measure for COPD Readmissions is 12.3% for your 2024 CMS Star Rating. Here are some practical challenges in aligning to the 12.3% example.

Time Lag Challenge

The time lag in published quality metrics presents a significant challenge in aligning physician incentives with quality programs. For instance, the CMS Star Ratings for 2024 utilize data from July 1, 2019, to June 30, 2022 for the 12.3% COPD readmissions. This lag of 2-5 years between the performance period and the publication of ratings means that current clinical practices and improvements are not reflected in the data used to measure performance. Consequently, aligning physician incentives to these outdated metrics can lead to misaligned incentives that do not accurately represent the current state of care delivery.

Out-of-Hospital Data Challenge

A critical challenge in aligning physician incentives with quality metrics is the inclusion of out-of-hospital data in the final CMS-published measures. For example, consider a hospital's COPD readmission rate, which is reported at 12.3%. This figure often encompasses readmissions occurring outside the hospital's data set. This presents challenges in understanding the total impact. Dexur published a series of articles on how out-of-hospital data could be 20-40% of total volume.

Risk Adjustment Challenge

The risk-adjusted rate presents another significant challenge in aligning physician incentives with quality metrics. For instance, consider the 12.3% readmission rate for COPD patients. This rate is risk-adjusted to account for the varying complexity of patient cases, ensuring a fair comparison across different hospitals. However, many hospitals lack the capability to perform accurate risk adjustments. The process involves complex algorithms that consider numerous patient factors such as comorbidities & age. Without these adjustments, hospitals might either be unfairly penalized or rewarded based on the raw readmission rates, which do not reflect the true performance. For example, a hospital treating a higher proportion of severe COPD cases might appear to perform poorly compared to one with less complex cases, simply because their patient population is inherently at higher risk of readmission. This misrepresentation can lead to misaligned incentives, where physicians are either discouraged from taking on high-risk patients or are not recognized for their efforts in managing more complex cases effectively. To address this, hospitals need to invest in sophisticated data analytics and risk adjustment tools that can accurately account for patient complexity, ensuring that the quality metrics used for physician incentives are both fair and representative of the true care quality.

Algorithm Complexity Challenge

The complexity of algorithms used in calculating quality metrics poses a substantial challenge for hospitals in aligning physician incentives accurately. Quality metrics such as the 12.3% COPD readmission rate involve intricate algorithms that factor in numerous variables and require precise implementation. However, many hospitals struggle with the sophisticated coding logic and detailed criteria these algorithms demand. Dexur wrote a detailed article on some of these challenges. The reasons in managing algorithm complexity include inappropriate coding logic in denominators, errors in numerator exclusions, misidentification of patient populations, faulty implementation of scoring algorithms, compromised data engineering pipelines, inadequate validation processes, and unaligned metric definitions.

How Dexur Helps Hospitals Align Physician Incentives to Quality Programs & Measures

Aligning physician incentives to quality programs and measures is essential for improving healthcare outcomes and operational efficiency. Dexur provides a comprehensive solution that addresses the challenges hospitals face in this alignment, leveraging complete patient journey data, risk adjustment capabilities, and advanced algorithm expertise. Here’s how Dexur’s capabilities can bridge the gap between internal observed rates and final CMS published values.

Comprehensive Patient Journey Data from Medicare Claims

Dexur brings the complete patient journey data from Medicare claims, covering both in-hospital and out-of-hospital events. This comprehensive data capture ensures that hospitals have a holistic view of patient outcomes, including readmissions, which are critical for accurate quality metric calculations. For example, Dexur’s access to detailed Medicare claims data allows hospitals to track COPD readmissions occurring outside their facilities, which could account for 20-40% of the total readmissions. This data integration helps in overcoming the challenge of incomplete data capture, ensuring that hospitals can align their performance metrics with the full spectrum of patient care.

Advanced Risk Adjustment Capabilities

Dexur has robust capabilities to perform sophisticated risk adjustments, accounting for various patient factors such as comorbidities, age, and socio-economic status. These adjustments are crucial for fair and accurate performance assessments. For instance, the 12.3% COPD readmission rate is a risk-adjusted figure that ensures hospitals treating more complex cases are not unfairly penalized. Dexur’s risk adjustment processes ensure that hospitals can achieve an accurate representation of their performance, aligning physician incentives more effectively with the true quality of care provided.

Expertise in Algorithm Implementation

Dexur’s expertise in algorithm implementation ensures precise calculations of quality metrics. This includes the accurate application of coding rules, defining numerator exclusions, and implementing scoring algorithms such as HCAHPS Linear Mean scores or SIR risk adjustments. Dexur’s algorithms address common pitfalls in metric calculations, such as inappropriate coding logic and errors in data engineering pipelines, which can lead to inaccurate performance metrics. By ensuring the integrity and accuracy of these calculations, Dexur helps hospitals maintain reliable and trustworthy quality metrics.

Bridging Internal Observed Rates to Final CMS Published Rates

Dexur can utilize its comprehensive data and algorithm expertise to ingest hospitals’ internal data and provide an internal observed rate that can be tracked on a monthly basis. This internal observed rate can then be bridged to the final CMS published values, typically available 2-5 years later. Here’s how this bridging process works:

  1. Monthly Tracking of Internal Observed Rates: Dexur provides hospitals with tools to calculate and monitor their internal observed readmission rates, such as the observed COPD readmission rate, on a monthly basis. This real-time tracking helps hospitals stay updated on their performance and make timely adjustments.

  2. Risk Adjustment Application: Dexur applies advanced risk adjustment models to these internal observed rates, accounting for patient demographics and clinical characteristics. This ensures that the internal metrics reflect a fair comparison across different patient populations.

  3. Algorithm Calibration and Validation: Dexur continuously calibrates and validates its algorithms against the latest data to ensure accuracy. This includes aligning internal metrics with the definitions and standards used by CMS.

  4. Bridging to Final CMS Rates: Using the comprehensive patient data and validated algorithms, Dexur bridges the internal observed rates to the final CMS published rates. For example, the internal observed COPD readmission rate, once adjusted and validated, can be correlated with the final 12.3% risk-adjusted readmission rate published by CMS. This bridging process involves predictive modeling and trend analysis to ensure that the internal metrics are on track to meet the expected final values.

By providing hospitals with these capabilities, Dexur enables a seamless alignment of physician incentives with quality programs and measures. This alignment not only improves patient outcomes and operational efficiency but also ensures that hospitals can proactively manage their performance in line with CMS standards.